← Return to search results
Back to Prindle Institute
EnvironmentTechnology

Shining a Light on Reflect Orbital

Daniel Burkett
By Daniel Burkett
18 Nov 2026

Last month, residents near the town of Lone Pine, California witnessed a strange – and somewhat disturbing – experiment. On an otherwise dark night, an area of their rural countryside was brightly lit. The experiment was a proof-of-concept for Reflect Orbital – a US company that plans to put 50,000 satellites into orbit over the next decade, each armed with a large mirror capable of reflecting sunlight onto the Earth during the dark of night. No such satellites yet exist – the Lone Pine test was carried out using large mobile lights stationed on a nearby mountaintop. But the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has already approved Reflect Global’s plan to launch its first test satellite – Eärendil-1 – next year. That one satellite alone will be capable of reflecting sunlight in three-mile wide beams ranging from the brightness of a full moon to the brightness of the sun at noon.

Reflect Global claims noble ambitions for how its satellites will be used. Chief among these is assisting search-and-rescue operations – making it easier to find imperiled individuals during nighttime operations (think the “cue the sun” scene from The Truman Show). But there are many other applications, too. Their website lists “extended working hours,” “boosted (agricultural) yields,” and “unforgettable nighttime experiences for events and public spaces” among the touted benefits. Put simply: Reflect Orbital’s satellites mean more sunlight – and more sunlight means more ways to make money.

Many are understandably aghast at the prospect of sunlight on demand. But can we go so far as to claim that Reflect Orbital’s actions are wrong? One way in which we might approach this question is to be consequentialist in our reasoning: that is, to ask whether the benefits of this project might outweigh any potential costs. The ability to enhance search-and-rescue operations – and, presumably, save lives – is certainly a desirable outcome. But it’s unclear whether it’s sufficiently weighty to offset the myriad harms. A joint letter from the Presidents of the European Biological Rhythms Society (EBRS), the Society for Research on Biological Rhythms (SRBR), the Japanese Society for Chronobiology (JSC) and the Canadian Society for Chronobiology (CSVC) argues that modifying the day/night cycle in this way could adversely disrupt the biological clocks that regulate sleep and hormone secretion in humans and animals, migration in nocturnal species, seasonal cycles in plants, and the rhythms of marine phytoplankton that underpin ocean food ecosystems. As Jan Hasselman – a senior attorney with environmental group Earthjustice – puts it:

“This is an idiotic project… There are a huge number of unresolved questions and significant potential impacts. Literally all of life on Earth evolved based on the rhythm of day and night and there is a ton of data showing that messing with this is not a good idea.”

But perhaps this is uncharitable to Reflect Orbital – who also cite environmental benefits to their project. The most obvious of these is the ability to “expand solar potential, making clean power… available when you need it.” Put simply, the ability to reflect sunlight would allow us to make greater use of solar power, reducing our dependence on fossil fuels and reducing carbon emissions.

As someone who works in climate justice, I find this an awfully tempting proposal. But it’s fraught with potential risks. As David Ho – a climate scientist at the University of Hawaii – notes:

“Global warming is happening because the Earth has a radiative imbalance due to the massive amounts of greenhouse gases we’ve dumped into the atmosphere… Some people are promoting the already unhinged idea of installing space mirrors facing away from the Earth to reflect the sun’s energy in order to decrease global warming. Imagine wanting to turn those mirrors around so that the Earth gets hotter.”

And there are less serious – though arguably still important – concerns too. One of these is light pollution. Studies show that the number of satellites currently in orbit has increased the amount of diffuse night sky brightness by around 10% – making the night less dark, and the stars less bright. The addition of fifty thousand more satellites will only make matters worse. And that’s to say nothing of the light pollution caused when those satellites begun deliberately reflecting sunlight back to earth.

Several years ago, I considered some of the moral arguments against SpaceX’s Starlink “mega-constellation,” focusing on the idea that an unpolluted sky is both extrinsically and intrinsically valuable. More recently, I explored the idea of space being a sort of global (or “galactic”) commons – there for the enjoyment of all. All of this might provide the basis for a new kind of argument – one based in rights. Each of us, we might argue, has a right to an unfettered view of an unpolluted sky. More fundamentally, we might also have a right to darkness.

Reflect Orbital’s plans directly violate both of those rights. What’s interesting about rights-based arguments is that they work regardless of consequentialist considerations. Put simply: it’s morally wrong to violate someone’s right, even if doing so might lead to good consequences. On this approach, it doesn’t matter if there are noble goods to be achieved by Reflect Orbital’s scheme. It doesn’t matter if there’s more money to be made, or if search-and-rescue operations can be enhanced, or if wartime operations can be more effectively executed (yes, that’s an additional touted benefit). If this project directly violates the rights of those of us back here on earth, Reflect Orbital will automatically be doing something wrong. And before they launch their first satellite, this is something they need to reflect on.

Daniel Burkett
Daniel Burkett received his PhD in Philosophy from Rice University, and is now a lecturer in the Philosophy Department at Binghamton University. His primary research interests are in ethics and political philosophy – particularly issues surrounding punishment and climate change.
Related Stories