← Return to search results
Back to Prindle Institute

From Concentration Camp to Hotel

By Amy Brown
28 Jan 2016

Mamula, an island situated on the border of Montenegro and Croatia, was the site of a World War II Italian concentration camp, in which 2,300 people were imprisoned and 130 or so were killed. Now, the Montenegrin government has agreed to a project to transform the island into a resort – a stark contrast to the fate of other concentration camps across Europe, which largely remain empty or act as memorial museums.

There has been international outrage over the decision to transform the island into a resort. Family members of the victims of the camp have called the plans disrespectful, and a “blatant example of lack of seriousness towards history.” Families, who often pay respects to the victims by visiting the island site on September 14, believe that creating a resort space on the island will destroy the memory of what the island really was. The Mamula camp is an integral, dark part of numerous families’ history, and they are concerned about the loss of this space. Many also agree that something should be done with the site, but in an educational aspect, rather than a commercial venture. The issue is not the development of tourism on the island, but rather the development of a luxury resort targeted toward wealthy clients that is seen as unethical, rather than educational tourism, which would be the more ethical approach. Many prominent international figures – including the former director of UNESCO – have sent letters to Parliament expressing their disapproval. Many also believe the rent is too low to justify the permission to build a resort.

The Montenegrin government acknowledges the concerns of the families, but reminds the world that the proposed site plans do include a memorial and museum that will be open year-round, even when the resort itself is closed for the season. Many believe this is a valid compromise. The government says that the transformation of the site will boost tourism and improve the overall economy of the country. They had to make a choice between finding investors willing to renovate and restore the property, or let the site fall into ruin, according to the head of Montenegro’s national directorate for tourism development. With the memorial and museum, even locals have approved of the proposal. This side of the argument sees the museum combined with the economic development as ethical for the country.

Is it ethical to place a resort on the site of a former concentration camp? Should all sites with a dark history be only developed through an educational lens? Is there a certain time period, or criteria which would allow certain land to be changed and developed over time compared to other historical locations? This is not the first time the repurposing of concentration camps has raised controversy, and likely will not be the last.

Amy graduated from DePauw University in 2017, and was a Hillman Intern and the Digital Media Assistant Managing Editor at the Prindle Institute for Ethics. At DePauw, she was an Honor Scholar and Political Science major with a Russian studies minor. She has spent time abroad in the Czech Republic and now works in Washington, D.C.
Related Stories

Diversity in Children's Books: A White Author's Quandary (Part II)

This post originally appeared September 29, 2015. In Part One of this two-part post on the moral importance of providing children with diverse books, I concluded that white authors need to write about non-white characters, or else they gravely falsify the “reality” presented in their stories. We don’t live in an all-white world. We don’t … Continue reading "Diversity in Children’s Books: A White Author’s Quandary (Part II)"

Diversity in Children's Books: A White Author's Quandary (Part I)

This post originally appeared September 22, 2015. For the first time in census history, the majority of children living in the United States are now children of color. But the vast majority of children living within the pages of American children’s books are white. According to the Cooperative Children’s Book Center of the University of … Continue reading "Diversity in Children’s Books: A White Author’s Quandary (Part I)"

A Libertarian Perspective On Gendered Bathroom Segregation

Recently in the United States, bathroom usage rights for transgender people have come to the political fore. As a part of Title IX protections against gender discrimination in federally funded educational institutions, the Obama administration has recently ordered public schools to allow students to use whichever bathrooms they please. This should free transgender students from … Continue reading "A Libertarian Perspective On Gendered Bathroom Segregation"